When a Scout has completed all the requirements for a rank, he appears before a Board of Review (BOR) composed of at least three, but no more than five members of the Troop Committee. The purpose of the review is to ensure that the requirements have been met for advancement; to help the boys grow in maturity; to be able to demonstrate the ability to relate and respect authority at the Scout level and the adult level; to show proficiency in Scout Skills; and to develop Scout Spirit and Godly Character. The board may review all aspects of the Scout's performance, leadership, and participation. The review is to encourage him to keep working toward advancement and a tool to be used for quality control of the entire program. If the requirements listed above are met, the the Scout will be awarded his rank. A BOR may also be held to counsel a boy about his lack of progress toward advancement.

Eagle Board of Review

The Advancement Chairman, through the District Advancement Chairman, whose guidelines will be followed, will arrange the BOR for the rank of Eagle. The District Advancement Chairman, or their representative, will convene the Board. Two Troop Committee members, familiar with the candidate, are requested to participate. No SM or ASM may participate. At this review, every aspect of the Scout's career may be reviewed at the discretion of the District representative. It is at this time that the strict adherence to the rules regarding tenure, advancement, and other aspects of the Scouts career is essential.